
Written By John R. Greenwood | Photo provided

Yes, I have Progressive Insurance. And yes, I can identify as both a parent and an offspring, but I have mixed feelings about Dr. Rick and Progressive Insurance's “Don’t become your parents” ad campaign. The ads can make me smile and cringe multiple times in 30 seconds. Although I’m a septuagenarian and I identify with just about every bit they spit out there, I can’t help but feel some anger over my insurance provider mocking me and the two people who spent 18 years molding me into a decent human being.
Apparently, I’m not the only one caught in this moral dilemma, because an internet search (yes, I know how to do that) unearthed several others who also had a love/hate reaction to the ads. I actually found a podcast that interviewed an executive at Arnold Worldwide, the ad agency that created the campaign. It was an interesting and thought-provoking ping-pong of opinions about my exact struggle. When asked if the ads caused any negative feedback, he said the success and overwhelming support for Dr. Rick and his classes far outweighed the negative. That might be the problem right there. It’s called dollars and cents versus right and wrong.
In another video short, an interviewer asks two comedians about the commercials. The female, though laughing at the questions, responds. “They’re painful because I see myself in them,” while her male colleague says, “They’re hilarious!”

Further scrolling (yes, I know how to do that too) revealed another short video where a woman in her twenties smiled when asked about the ads. She agreed they were funny but didn’t like some of the messages we were sending to her generation. She said in one of Dr. Rick’s ‘Don’t Become Your Parents’ classes, he tells his students, “You don’t need to keep the empty butter container.” She said, “That bothers me. Let’s not frame reusing things, saving money, and being sustainable as an out-of-touch old people thing. Don’t tell young people that’s embarrassing. Because it’s a good thing and everybody wins. You don’t have to buy containers, and you’re not throwing away so much plastic. You’re getting more use out of things.” Some of us might summon our Sgt. Hulka and say, “Lighten up, Francis.” But she’s right about the negative messages we’re filling young people's heads with.
This is where I join the fray. Look closely at the photo at the top of the page. Please don’t suggest it’s wrong for me to want to become one of the people who taught me to say please and thank you, to sit up straight, to get to work on time, to hold a door, pick up a piece of litter, respect my elders, brush my teeth, comb my hair, and to always treat others as you would like them to treat you. That last one is the one we should all live by. It’s also the one that sways me to feel more negative than positive about Dr. Rick and his teachings. Deep down, I think we all crave more positive messaging these days. Laughing at people whose looks, behavior, or beliefs don’t match ours is exactly what we need to discourage, not encourage. We’ve created a nightmare that will take another generation to dismantle, and we should start with the next ad campaign.
Don’t think I’m being an old curmudgeon; I’m only looking out for my great-granddaughter. She deserves a generation of people looking out for each other, not one overrun with disrespect and finger-pointing. Will I keep laughing at myself and learning to take a joke? Yes, Dr. Rick, I will, but don’t for one minute think that, even with some of my parents' missteps and those of their generation, I’m not grateful every day for who they were and how they raised me.