Written By Charlie Kuenzel photos provided by the George Bolster Collection

Growing up in this great city I was told many wonderful stories of the “old days.” I’m sure many of those stories were exaggerated or embellished over the years as they were re-told to different generations.

Here is one that has been brought back to the truth.

Gideon and Doanda Putnam were very instrumental in the early development of the city. They initially rented land and eventually bought it to construct a few buildings with the most important one being the first hotel, Putnam’s Tavern and Boarding House. Located on the north-west corner of Broadway and Congress Street, Putnam’s opened for business in the summer of 1802.

Gideon realized the success of his hotel was rooted in the belief that people would visit the mineral springs found in the village for health reasons. Since the mineral springs were so important to his economic success, he proposed a few fundamental rules. In June of 1811 he published a list of three rules for residents and visitors alike. The rules on the list intended to protect the safety of the waters, so they prohibited the practice of allowing animals to contaminate the springs or the introduction of other wastes. The most important rule was that the waters would always be free at the spring. It allowed the waters to be bottled so that they could be shipped for profit, but at the spring the water would always be free. Gideon felt you should not pay for your health at the spring. Gideon felt so strongly about this that he wanted to place the springs in the middle of the streets near their source, so no one owned them. When Gideon died in 1812 the springs slowly moved back to private land, but the water was NEVER charged for at the spring, except in one location.

Daniel McLaren was a businessman and land owner who eventually bought a piece of property that today is the site of the Pavilion Hotel on Lake Avenue. In 1840 he worked hard to get a mineral spring called the Pavilion on the site to flow freely. The spring was in a very swampy area and required great effort and cost. Upon completion of the work, a bill of $4,000 for construction was given to McLaren and was so high that he felt he should have a daily charge of $.50 per person/one dollar for a family, to consume the water at the Pavilion Spring. These daily charges would help pay for this costly project. Saratogians were outraged and began to protest the violation of Gideon’s Rule. The crowds cried out that this tax on water was the “Stamp Act” of Saratoga.  After a few days of demonstrations, the wooden cover and bottling house of the Pavilion Spring mysteriously burned to the ground one night. McLaren dropped his daily water charge.

That event served as a reminder to others that Gideon’s rule should never be violated, and that request is honored, still today.

Simply Saratoga

Simply Saratoga Magazine is published  by Saratoga Publishing, LLC, who brings you such award-winning niche magazines as Saratoga Bride, Saratoga Family, Welcome Home and the weekly newspaper, Saratoga TODAY!

We love Saratoga Springs! The people, the shops, the history, and of course racing season. Our Mission is to bring you everything Saratoga.

Find Us!

The People - The Places - The Lifestyle

Contact Us!

We would love to hear from you.

  • Visit us at Five Case Street, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
  • Call us at (518) 581-2480
  • Email us at: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Website Design & Hosting by Spa City Digital